However, it can be difficult to determine which pacifier is ideal for a breastfed infant. We have, however, done some of the legwork for you to make this job a bit less daunting. Let’s take a look at the pacifier’s primary function and see if we still need them. For fussy infants, a pacifier can be a lifesaver, especially before bedtime or during nap time. They provide a soothing effect, aid in establishing healthy sleep routines, and ease your child’s anxiety. Your baby will have fun exploring the wide variety of shapes, colors, and designs available, and they won’t be able to spit them out because to the various textures. Check out our list and reviews of the best pacifiers for breastfeeding babies if you’re having trouble deciding which one to put on your baby registry.
11 Best Pacifiers For A Breastfed Baby
Best BPA-Free: Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Giraffe Pacifier
The Philips Avent Soothie Snuggle Pacifier is the perfect solution if you’re seeking for a lightweight plush toy that can also serve as a pacifier. These bright and appealing toys are simple for infants to grasp and can be used to divert attention away from any loud noises. This orthodontic silicone nipple pacifier is BPA-free, has a soft shield that allows your baby to breathe, and is soft and flexible. The pacifier may be removed from the stuffed animal so it can be washed in the dishwasher or sterilized in boiling water. This pacifier is great since it is permanently tied to the snuggling giraffe thus it will never go missing. If you need more proof, you may watch this YouTuber’s review of the product.
- Separatable for hassle-free maintenance
- Contain no bisphenol A
- High-strength, pliable silicone that meets medical standards
- Supple and light
- may be sterilized, reprocessed, or discarded
- If you tug too hard on the pacifier, it may come out.
Best Anti-Slip: MAM Night Orthodontic Pacifiers
The MAM Night Pacifiers are adorable and practical, with a skin-friendly design and a BPA-free silicone nipple in a symmetrical form that is great for your baby’s teeth and jaw development. This pacifier was designed by eminent pediatric dentists and psychologists specializing in early childhood development for use by infants aged six months or less. Its luminescence makes it visible even after dark. These pacifiers include a cover that curves to fit the shape of a baby’s mouth and has large cutouts to allow for easy breathing. This night pacifier comes with a built-in sterilizer and a carrying case, making it easy to keep clean and ready for use. Check out this YouTube review to learn more about this product and how it can benefit you.
- Nipple stays put thanks to the nonslip material.
- Equal nip
- Protective layer with a textured surface to lessen skin sensitivity
- It’s possible that the pacifier will become damp from the condensation.
Best Lightweight: Tommee Tippee Ultra-Light Pacifier
The nipple of the Tommee Tippee ultra-light silicone soother is designed to encourage healthy jaw and teething development in infants. Your infant will feel comfortable because the 100% medical-grade silicone is pliable and has a skin-like texture. The big holes in this pacifier provide for plenty of ventilation, and the curved shield is made to fit snuggly between your baby’s nose and chin. This clean pacifier has anti-static qualities to discourage dust from settling on it, which can prevent skin irritations. This one-piece, kid-friendly design comes in three sizes and can be cleaned in the dishwasher. Check out this review by a popular YouTuber if you still have doubts.
- Enhances proper jaw and tooth growth
- Constructed entirely of 100% hypoallergenic medical-grade silicone
- non-tasting and odorless; doesn’t hold spills or stains
- The ability to resist static electricity
- Quick to put away any accumulated grime
- Depending on your expectations, the size may be too big or too little.
Best Dishwasher-Safe: NUK Orthodontic Pacifier Value Pack
In a set of three, the NUK Orthodontic Pacifier has a more comfortable nipple. This pacifier, designed by pediatric dentists and specialists, mimics the curve of a baby’s nipple while breastfeeding, making the switch from breast to pacifier less jarring for your little one. The asymmetrical shape of the nipple relieves pressure on your baby’s developing teeth by conforming to the shape of their palate. The gray bees set includes a breast-shaped pacifier that glows in the dark in case it gets misplaced. This NUK pacifier is great if you’re looking for a pacifier for a baby up to six months old.
- Nipples made of silicone, molded into an orthodontically ideal shape
- The heart-shaped face shield makes it easier to breathe.
- Option that glows in the dark
- Could be too big for premature infants.
Chicco PhysioForma Orthodontic Silicone Pacifier
This premium orthodontic silicone pacifier is ideal if you’re searching for a pacifier that’s both soft and flexible. This pacifier has a shaped shield and four air holes for increased air circulation, making it a good choice for babies with eczema or other moisture-related issues. Baby’s respiration will be actively supported while latched on to these ultra-soft nipples. The nipple’s slant and lateral curvature disperse your baby’s tongue pressure evenly throughout his or her palate. Tiny ridges and an angled nipple shape guide your baby’s tongue into the right place for the sake of his or her developing palate and teeth. This one-piece pacifier is ideal since it is constructed of safe, food-grade silicone and has a comfortable grip for both baby and parent.
- Produced from premium grade silicone that is both durable and pliable.
- a breathable, contoured shield
- Breathing aids with extra-gentle nipples
- Carrying grip that’s not too tough to get a hold of
- Includes a sterile carrying and storage case
- One possible side effect of prolonged use is discoloration of the pacifier.
Best Wear-Resistant: Bibs Baby Pacifier
The BIBS Baby Pacifier is often considered the best round pacifier available. This pacifier’s cherry-shaped nipple mimics the form and texture of a mother’s breast to lull your baby to sleep. Nursing and a healthy sucking reflex are encouraged by the form. The nipple is made of 100% natural rubber latex, making it soft and pliable. There is a hole in the nipple that allows air to escape. These pacifiers come in three sizes and are made without the use of harmful substances like BPA, PVC, or phthalates.
- provides the means for calming oneself
- Chemicals like BPA, PVC, and phthalates aren’t present at all in any amount.
- capability of sterilization
- Produced from a natural rubber latex that is both soft and pliable.
- With a built-in air release, it can be used in any situation
- Polypropylene barrier designed to withstand repeated wear and tear (PP)
- After a few months of use, some customers noticed that the nipple had stretched out little.
Best Durable: Itzy Ritzy Sweetie Soother Silicone Pacifiers
Baby can relax in style with one of these adorable pacifiers from Itzy Ritzy. Each pacifier is constructed from 100% food-grade silicone, is latex-free, and features a unique design on the handle to complement your baby’s wardrobe. These BPA-free pacifiers meet or exceed all applicable ASTM safety standards and feature two ventilation holes. They come in a set of two with a gray and a yellow pacifier, and are great for newborns up until they start teething. The set’s complementary pacifier pod provides a space-saving way to transport and carry two pacifiers.
- Created from silicone that is safe for consumption,
- Includes 2 big breathing holes.
- The combination of a soft and long-lasting texture
- Incorporates a foldable handle for convenience and security.
- There may be a little rubbery aroma to this pacifier.
Best Flexible: Evenflo Feeding Balance + Pacifier
This 100% silicone easy-to-clean design was created in collaboration with pediatric feeding experts and should be on every mom and baby’s registry. Infants up to six months of age can benefit from the Evenflo Balance Plus Stage 1 Pacifier since it promotes healthy sucking habits. This is because babies are more likely to mimic the breastfeeding position, in which their tongues are in a more rounded, natural shape, when using a cylindrical object. Baby’s skin will stay dry thanks to the mesh vents, and you’ll appreciate the soft, comfortable handles. The curved faceplate of this one-piece soft silicone design makes it comfortable for your infant to suck on for longer.
- The perfect combination of portability and adaptability
- There are built-in air vents
- Encourages a wagging tongue and a cupped fist
- This clear soother could be tricky to track down late at night.
Best Ergonomic Design: Nanobebe Flexy Baby Pacifier
This Nanobebe Flexy Pacifier is perfect for use in calming and soothing a newborn without the risk of nipple confusion. To ensure your baby’s comfort, the silicone is extremely soft and is devoid of harmful chemicals like BPA and phthalates. Your infant will have an easier time keeping the pacifier in his or her mouth due to the pacifier’s small weight and ergonomic design. No of the time of day or night, Nanobebe’s silicone pacifiers will quiet your baby and put an end to his or her crying. Use these pacifiers to help your baby learn to calm down on his or her own in the period between meals, in the car, and at bedtime. Each silicone pacifier is gentle on your child’s teething gums and promotes healthy habits for a lifetime of dental health.
- Comfy nipple made from extra-soft material.
- Effortless and comfortable to carry
- Produced from silicone
- The absence of bisphenol A and phthalates
- This pacifier may be too tiny for some babies.
Best Latex-Free: The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifiers
The First Years GumDrop Newborn Pacifiers feature a revolutionary one-piece design made from safe, latex-free silicone. These newborn baby pacifiers are available in a variety of bright colors, and they are designed to fit the baby’s face so that they can breathe normally. This pacifier is light enough for your infant to hold and works with a wide variety of attachments. They come in a variety of cheery, eye-catching hues, and its distinctive, contoured shape makes it easy for your baby to self-soothe.
- Distinctly curved design
- An alternative to latex pacifiers
- Portable and lightweight
- Multiple hues are readily accessible.
- Fits infants aged 0-3 months
- The pacifier is not suitable for the dishwasher.
Ryan And Rose Cutie Pacifier And Teether
For teething infants, we recommend Ryan and Rose’s pacifier and teether set. This product does not include any BPA, PVC, phthalates, or latex, and is made entirely of medical-grade silicone. This pacifier can also be used as a teething toy, making it a great choice for your growing baby. To use it as a teether, simply attach it to a clip, and tuck the nipple out of the way. The soother is mild on the gums, and the pacifier’s soft nipple helps your baby’s palate develop in a way that’s similar to when you breastfeed. The convenient one-piece design makes it easy to disinfect and eliminates the breeding ground for germs. Because of the pacifiers’ basic color scheme, you’ll have no trouble pairing them with your baby’s wardrobe.
- Nipple is rounded and very gentle.
- Smooth, integrated construction
- Large, round protection for the teeth
- The use of ventilation holes to increase airflow
- Featuring a sturdy grip for convenient use.
- The nipple could be too tight for your comfort.
Finding the Right Pacifier for Your Breastfed Infant
The following considerations should help you select the best pacifier for your infant.
Age of the Child:
Breastfed infants do not need a pacifier until they are about three to four weeks old. You should just make sure they have a basic grasp of feeding before trying anything else to soothe them down. Mothers and babies can benefit from pacifiers because they can assist infants become acclimated to self-soothing, which can take some time. Most pacifier users fall within the 0-36-month age range. During this time, you may want to give your opinion on a few potential courses of action.
Shades and forms:
Dentist-recommended asymmetrical orthodontic pacifiers facilitate infant mouthing and promote healthy teeth development. However, your baby’s preference should be taken into account when deciding between a curved and straight pacifier. Pick something that doesn’t require disassembly before being put in the dishwasher so you can spend less time doing dishes. Two-piece pacifiers should be avoided because of the risk of suffocation if one piece were to break off. To soothe a baby, a pacifier with a fun design and vivid colors is ideal. To aid in nighttime discovery, they feature glow-in-the-dark accents.
Material and size:
The material and size of a pacifier should be your primary concerns. Pacifiers are often made of either latex or silicone, both of which are safe and effective options. A silicone pacifier is an option if your child has a latex allergy, which is something to keep in mind. It’s also important that the pacifier you choose is safe, without any harmful substances like PVC or phthalates. These calming pacifiers are made with safe composition materials that won’t harm your baby.
Expert reviewer and midwife/lactation consultant Regina Kincaid recommends round or cylindrical pacifiers because they remind babies of a mother’s nipple, making them feel safe and secure. Don’t forget to replace it if it gets damaged or outdated, and always go with the appropriate size for your baby’s age.
Frequently Asked Questions
What are the risks of giving a baby a pacifier?
There are no major hazards associated with using a pacifier with your child, but improper use can lead to nipple confusion, habit building, reliance, and even permanent teeth damage. You or your kid might need some time to adjust. If you’re a parent worried about the effects of a pacifier on your child’s teeth, you may rest easy knowing that it won’t cause any harm unless the pacifier is used for a very long time. It’s also important to frequently disinfect the pacifier so it doesn’t spread germs to your child.
Are Tommee Tippee pacifiers orthodontic?
The answer is yes. The shape of a Tommee Tippee pacifier differs somewhat from the standard orthodontic pacifier. Nipple shapes on bottles are designed to mimic the feel of a baby’s natural nip, making them more comfortable for the infant.
Do I need to get a BPA-free pacifier?
Absolutely, while shopping for a pacifier, you should check to see if it is BPA-free. Nipples made of medical-grade silicone are an alternative to latex nipples, which can trigger allergic reactions in some infants.
Should I get a rounded nipple or orthodontic nipple pacifier?
Long and narrow, with a rounded tip that mimics the human nipple, this style of pacifier is commonly used in Europe. In order to prevent your infant from developing tooth issues, orthodontic pacifiers are flatter on one side and more oval shaped. The rounded nipple design may be preferable for breastfed infants because it is more like a mother’s nipple. Try the round variety first, then the orthodontic variety.
When should I replace a pacifier?
A pacifier should be replaced when you see a hole, discolored areas, or a strained nipple. If the plastic on the pacifier’s guard or handle has sharpened or if the pacifier is loose in some places, you might consider getting a new one.
Are pacifiers bad for a baby’s teeth?
Dentists have found that the usage of pacifiers by some infants may contribute to abnormal oral development and even the development of permanent teeth too soon. It’s likely that a misaligned bite or crooked teeth will be the first problem you encounter. You can prevent these issues by waiting to wean your child off the pacifier until after they turn two.
Parents can’t do without pacifiers, but they’re especially useful at nap time when babies can get irritable. These are great for your baby’s teeth and jaw development and also aid in a more restful night’s sleep. On top of that, it facilitates a natural change from breastfeeding to bottle feeding. Make sure the pacifier you choose for your baby is composed of a soft, lightweight, flexible, and food-grade material, and that it can be easily cleaned. In addition, it needs to be visually appealing and simple to use so that it can both stimulate and calm your infant.